Live!
Thu 21 Sep 2017
- The award-winning student news website of Imperial College

Know something you shouldn't? Tell us, using our quick, 100% anonymous tip-off form!

Live! - News

Engineers and Scientists Say No, Medics Say Yes

Dec 12 2006 22:27
Ashley Brown
The Returning Officer for the NUS referendum has released his report, revealing the divisions within College.
NUS democracy card - this one is free

The Returning Officer's report on the NUS referendum was presented to council tonight, with some interesting information about the breakdown of results.

The faculties voted in the following way (% Yes/No):

  • Engineering - 48/52
  • Natural Sciences - 49/51
  • Medicine - 68/32

The medic vote was sufficient to change the result from a narrow 'No' victory to a narrow 'Yes' victory, with non-Faculty voters (Tanaka, the Sabbatical Officers) also contributing to the swing. Freshers were marginally in favour, coming in at 54/46, while non-Freshers were 49/51 against.

Departments against affiliation were Physics, Mechanical Engineering, Aeronautics, Bioengineering, Civil Engineering, Mathematics and Computing. When speaking for the 'Yes' campaign ICU President John Collins was booed in Mechanical Engineering, something which is reflected in the result with Mech Eng being the most anti-NUS department.

Materials, Chemistry, ESE, EEE, Centre for Environmental Policy, Chemical Engineering, Medicine, Life Sciences and Tanaka were all in favour of affiliation to varying degrees, with Tanaka being the most pro-NUS of the major departments.

During Council ICU President John Collins answered questions about the financial arrangements over the next few years. The initial £35k cost of affiliation for this academic year is likely to be part-paid by College, with the rest coming from Executive Committee reserves. Mr Collins indicated that the £44k cost next year will be fully covered by the money coming back when ICU leaves ULU.

Email this Article | Share on Facebook | Print this Article

Discussion about “Engineers and Scientists Say No, Medics Say Yes”

The comments below are unmoderated submissions by Live! readers. The Editor accepts no liability for their content, nor for any offence caused by them. Any complaints should be directed to the Editor.
1. Medic   
Dec 12 2006 23:41
 

Of course, the Medic president did campain shamlessly to medic freshers under his titile, making this unsurprising.

Dec 13 2006 09:25
 

I'd like to put it on the record that although I was booed in Mech Eng, every other department I visited was far more welcoming!

Dec 13 2006 12:21
 

medics are idiots, end of story. they basically did what they were told by their glorious 'leader'. too bad they can't think for themselves.

Dec 13 2006 14:14
 

It is not fair to say that. 32% of the medic did vote No! and well done to them.

Dec 13 2006 14:33
 

Been a while since I was on Live! You guys still dicussing the NUS? This must be 199something or is that 2001?

Dec 13 2006 14:39
 

Well, we did have the whole NUS referendum thing last month....

7. Pan   
Dec 13 2006 17:00
 

If they want it that bad, it would then seem more appropriate to only affiliate ICSM with NUS. "Respect our wishes"

8. Sid   
Dec 14 2006 09:35
 

What would be interesting is to see the turn out in the faculties - because I suspect the Medics probably managed to get more people to vote - they always do.

Dec 14 2006 10:40
 

Turnout by faculties:

Scientists: 32.62%

Engineers: 32.58%

Medics: 27.60%

Non-Faculty: 14.56%

Dec 15 2006 23:26
 

It would be interesting to see number rather than percentages.

Dec 16 2006 12:14
 

Scientists: 1383

Engineers: 1650

Medics: 853

Non-Faculty: 121

Total: 4007

Dec 16 2006 12:35
 

And people wonder why everyone hates the Medics...

Dec 16 2006 20:37
 

Seems that the percentages were more interesting than the numbers

Dec 16 2006 21:38
 

Sour grapes. If almost twice the number of us engineers couldn't effect the result we wanted, then so be it. We don't deserve to be able to moan about the result if only 30-odd percent of us could be bothered to vote.

Add your comment:

If you can see this, something is broken (either with your browser, or with our system). Please leave the box below empty, or your comment will be considered to be spam.
Live!

See Also

  1. Aston to Disaffiliate from the NUS
    30 Nov 06 | News
  2. NUS Referendum: Fair or Farce?
    20 Nov 06 | Editorial
  3. Glasgow NUS Referendum: Free and Fair?
    20 Nov 06 | Widening Participation

Live! Poll

How frequently would you like to see a CGCU magazine being published




Live!