Wed 21 Feb 2018
- The award-winning student news website of Imperial College

Know something you shouldn't? Tell us, using our quick, 100% anonymous tip-off form!

Live! - Opinion

This article is an opinion piece and should be taken as such. It is highly likely to be biased, but either the article itself or the ensuing discussion will probably be entertaining. Live! takes no editorial line on opinion pieces.

A State of Denial

Jul 29 2009 22:55
Chris Mullan, Strand Poly Outlaw
Ex King's College Union President, Chris Mullan, laments the branding of certain universities as 'elite'.
Chris Mullan.

It would be easy to attack Lord Mandleson's recent pronouncements on Higher Education by attacking his position as our un-elected overlord and de facto Prime Minister, but ad hominim attacks do not progress the debate.

Instead we should attack the same old tired clap track nonsense about Universities not doing enough for working class students. Time and time again, be it the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State for whatever department universities fall under this month, the President of the NUS, or indeed some unhinged Another Union is Possible wing nut, the same old stick is brought out with which to smack universities over the head with. It is depressing that my very first article on Live! was essentially about the same issue: using university bashing as a smoke screen to deflect from more fundamental and systemic issues in our education system.

To look behind the smoke and mirrors of the 'press release politics' we've experienced since 1997 is to see an Orwellian world in which new words define new ideas and realities, and the world in which the rest of us live becomes increasingly disconnected from the one that is described by the politicians. For if all of those annual announcements on how wonderfully well this years crop of A-level or GCSE students had fared were true, then the best universities would have a childlike ease in selecting working class applicants that meet the entry requirements instead of those same students being crowded out by 'evil' children whose parents paid.

If the improvements were genuine then the change would happen, if the change is manufactured and statistical, then the façade falls once the government looses the power to define success.

Fundamentally the problem comes not down to universities failing the working class, the hard truth is that the government has failed both the working class and society as a whole by not using 14 years of education to produce candidates able to get into the 'elite universities'.

Attacking universities means not having to address the failings of government. Attacking 'elite' universities belies the acceptance that the rapid broadening of the HE sector has not built institutions producing respected or indeed employable graduates. And to be honest, furthering the stereotype that elite graduates are both entitled to, and readily receive, high paid dream jobs is particularly spiteful with record graduate unemployment.

If only students had a strong national voice with which to challenge the weak premises that underlay Lord Mandelson?s comments. If only there was a national organisation that represented the 5 million FE students whom the data shows have the worst chance of all groups at getting into a good university, or the two million HE students soon to find themselves in the dole queue. If only.

Email this Article | Share on Facebook | Print this Article

Discussion about “A State of Denial”

The comments below are unmoderated submissions by Live! readers. The Editor accepts no liability for their content, nor for any offence caused by them. Any complaints should be directed to the Editor.
Jul 30 2009 11:05

Vote Chris Mullan for NUS Pres!!!!!!!!

2. Fred   
Jul 31 2009 13:42

He talks sense.

Jun 26 2013 09:16

Why lkkmotor so cheaper than any other seller?

I bought one complete <a href="" title=" Honda fairing "> Honda fairing </a> kits from lkkmotor 4 years ago on e bay, they sell on e bay only once. Right now I can get 8% discount from their own online <a href="" title=" motorcycle parts superstore "> motorcycle parts superstore </a>. I am sure lkkmotor is your best choose if you want to buying motorcycle fairing, the pirce is the best than any other Sellers, Because they are the <a href="" title=" motorcycle fairing factory "> motorcycle fairing factory </a>, almost all the fairing seller buy from his factory then sell it to us. All right I don't know the other <a href="" title="motorcycle parts"> motorcycle parts </a>. Maybe some one was cheaper than lkkmotor.Right now, lkkmotor pay me every month, and I send this article on all every forums. We can buy any <a href="" title=" sport bike parts "> sport bike parts </a> on their webstore. For example, <a href=" " title="Suzuki Fairings"> Suzuki Fairings</a>,<a href="" title="Yamaha Fairings">Yamaha Fairings </a>,<a href="" title="Kawasaki Fairings"> Kawasaki Fairings</a>,<a href="" title="Ducati Fairings">Ducati Fairings </a>,<a href="" title="Aprilia Fairings"> Aprilia Fairings</a>,<a href="" title="Frame Sliders">Frame Sliders </a>,<a href="" title="Windscreen Windshield"> Windscreen Windshield</a>,<a href="" title="Brake Clutch Levers">Brake Clutch Levers </a>,<a href="" title="Lighting and Mirrors">Lighting and Mirrors </a>,<a href="" title=Headlight>Headlight </a>,<a href="" title="LED Turn Signals">LED Turn Signals </a>,<a href="" title="Motorcycle Jacket"> </a>,<a href="" title="">Motorcycle Jacket </a>,<a href="" title=Speedometer>Speedometer</a>,<a href="" title="Rear Set">Rear Set</a>,<a href="" title="Chain Guard">Chain Guard</a>,<a href="" title="Rear Hugger Fender"> Rear Hugger Fender</a>,<a href="" title="Fender Eliminator"> Fender Eliminator</a>,<a href="" title="Stay Bracket">Stay Bracket </a>,<a href="" title="Riser Handlebar"> Riser Handlebar</a>,<a href="" title="Wheel Rim">Wheel Rim </a>,<a href="" title="Motorcycle Helmet">Motorcycle Helmet </a>,<a href="" title="Motorcycle Armour">Motorcycle Armour</a>,<a href="" title=""> </a>,<a href="" title="Motorcycle Gloves">Motorcycle Gloves </a>,<a href="" title="Motorcycle Boots&amp;Shoes"> Motorcycle Boots&Shoes</a>,<a href="" title="Motorcycle Caps"> Motorcycle Caps</a>. I have very happy purchase on lkkmotor, the service and product quality is also very good! I really Recommend !

Why lkkmotor so cheaper than any other seller?

Jun 26 2013 17:11


Jun 27 2013 02:35


Jun 27 2013 03:11

Regis High School

Jun 27 2013 04:45

Regis High School

Add your comment:

If you can see this, something is broken (either with your browser, or with our system). Please leave the box below empty, or your comment will be considered to be spam.

Also In Widening Participation

  1. A Statement from Chris Mullan
    10 Sep 08 | Widening Participation
  2. UCLU AGM: Racism, Bigotry and Pig-headedness
    10 Mar 08 | Widening Participation
  3. NUS President Losing Touch With Reality?
    17 Aug 07 | Widening Participation

See Also

  1. No Loans, No Fees
    10 Jul 09 | News
  2. Government Freezes Maintenance Grants
    02 Jul 09 | News
  3. Funding Our Future?
    10 Jun 09 | News

Live! Poll

How frequently would you like to see a CGCU magazine being published